Element
New Choice icon

New Choice

New Choice is a short-form improv game in which a host interrupts a running scene with "New choice!", forcing the last player to replace their line or action immediately.

ExerciseGameUseRehearsalShow

2–3 playersBeginnerhigh energy

Host, bell or whistle, audience suggestion

Creativity, Speed, Accepting, Search Game, Energetic, Exercise, Game, Offer, Other
favoriteLike

Add to Workshop

How to Play New Choice

  1. Start a scene from an audience suggestion.
  2. Let the host stop the scene at any moment with a whistle, a bell or a call of "New choice!".
  3. Replace your last line or action with a new one if you were the last to speak or move.
  4. Replace the same line again whenever "New choice!" comes a second or third time.
  5. Carry on with the latest choice as if it had always been part of the scene.

Tips

  • Make bold, radical choices instead of small word swaps: going from walking a dog to walking a cat to walking an elephant is the Rule of Threes, not a new choice.
  • A character's entrance is a great moment to call for a new choice, because it forces players to become someone they did not expect to be.
  • As host, fight your own habits and patterns too; once a player thinks they know your style, it is time to surprise them.
  • Do not call a new choice when players clearly expect one after a throwaway first line, so they have to continue with that line.
  • Do not go easy on new players: the game is nerve-racking but it demands exactly creativity, speed and confidence, and players who survive it are ready for anything.

What you train with it

  • ImpulseAct on the first idea instead of checking it first.
  • SpeedDecide and react quickly without stopping the scene.
  • AcceptingTake up and build on what others offer instead of blocking it.

Sources

  • New Choice

    improwikiCC BY-SA 3.0 DElast edited 2026-11-17

    Based on "New Choice" from improwiki

    Original text: New Choice

    New Choice is a short-form improv game in which a host can interrupt a scene at any moment by calling "New choice!" The player who just spoke or acted has to replace that line or action with a new one, and the scene continues from there. The game is also known as Should Have Said or Ding, after the bell some hosts use.

    How to play New Choice

    1. Players start a scene based on an audience suggestion.
    2. At any point the host blows a whistle, rings a bell or calls "New choice!"
    3. The player who spoke or acted last replaces their line or action with a new one.
    4. The host can call "New choice!" again and again on the same line, until they like what they hear.
    5. The scene continues with the latest choice as if it had always been there.

    The host can call for as many or as few new choices as they like.

    Tips for players

    Make bold, radical choices. This game tempts you to fall into the Rule of Threes. Fight it. For example:

    Bad example:

    • "I'm walking my dog."
    • "New choice!"
    • "I'm walking my cat."
    • "New choice!"
    • "I'm walking my elephant."
    • "New choice!"
    • "This is a stick-up. Give me all your money!"

    Good example:

    • "I'm walking my dog."
    • "New choice!"
    • "This is a stick-up. Give me all your money!"
    • "New choice!"
    • "I hate to be the one to tell you, but you're just not cut out to be an astronaut, Daniel."

    In the bad example, a dull, predictable pattern sets in: the same choice is repeated three times with only one word changed, and only then does a real alternative show up. Aim for the good example, avoid patterns and predictability, and take the scene in a new direction. Make NEW choices.

    Tips for the host

    • A character's entrance is a great moment to call for a new choice. It challenges players to be someone they didn't expect to be.
    • Beware the Rule of Threes yourself. Fight all habits and patterns. Once a player thinks they know your style, it's time to surprise them.
    • Players often offer a line they're sure you'll want replaced and then wait for your whistle. Surprise them by not calling a new choice, so they have to continue with that first line.
    • Many players expect their first choice to be rejected, so they offer a throwaway line first and save the "good" one for the second or third round. If a player is playing you like that, do the unexpected.

    Many new players find this game scary and nerve-racking. Don't go easy on them. Yes, it's extremely challenging: it puts huge pressure on players and demands creativity, speed and confidence. In short, it is improv. Players who get through this game are ready for anything.

    Related games

    Source note: the first version of this article was taken from atomiccomicimprov.wikispaces.com.

Related Elements